So what's new? There's no additional risk to Israeli decision-makers; they're already war criminals many times over simply for their disproportionate use of force, use of indiscriminate cluster munitions in civilian areas, and collective punishment against Lebanese people in 2006.
So, they have little to loose by declaring the entire geographic region of Gaza an "enemy entity." They think they can create a legal fiction, commit collective punishment by cutting off power and fuel supplies and get away with it. They are wrong.
I'm not alone in condemning Israeli leaders as war criminals on par with the most notorious in history. I boycott Israeli products, and speak freely of their atrocious behavior, their false claims of "good faith". I don't trust Israel at all. They have pushed me to challenge the legitimacy of the Israeli state.
Israel and the US have exposed themselves by blatantly undermining the legitimate results of the elections that gave Hamas a parliamentary majority.
I declare the current US and Israeli governments to be "enemies of democracy."
This isn't a legal fiction. Sufficient evidence exists to prove that this phrase applies to these governments, and continue to be a legal sickle hanging over the necks of specific decision makers after they leave office. They will be prosecuted. We will reclaim our democratic principles, institutions, and power.
Showing posts with label punishment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label punishment. Show all posts
September 19, 2007
January 14, 2007
Bush's war of Terrorism
We've all heard the logical refrain, "Terrorism is a tactic, not an enemy that we can target in a war, which means that the 'war on terrorism' is nothing of the sort." Yes, it's just a slogan, one the corporate mass media has been happy to adopt. Unfortunately, so have many progressive voices.
We need to reframe the issue. George Lakoff has introduced the concept of "framing" issues in the public discourse. The title of this essay is one such attempt. Another example is the phrase "the death tax." Once the mainstream debate on estate taxes is framed as "the death tax," an uphill battle is established. It's hard enough to be in favor of taxes, but being in favor of taxing people upon their death becomes even more implausible. Framing is key.
There can be no such thing as a "war on terrorism." Given ample evidence of domestic spying and police infiltration of organizations, new legal definitions like "enemy combatant" for which Geneva Conventions don't apply, the use of torture and renditions, the use of horrific weapons of war (ala "Shock and Awe"), the unleashing to death squads (ala the Salvador Option), adopting Israeli tactics of punishing the familiy members of insurgents [1], it isn't hyperbole to reframe Bush's war on terrorism to be called "Bush's war of terrorism."
Notes:
[1] One basic principle of urban warfare was described to New York Times reporter Dexter Filkins by a U.S. commander: “the new strategy must punish not only the guerrillas, but also make clear to ordinary Iraqis the cost of not cooperating.” According to Brigadier General Michael A. Vane, “We recently traveled to Israel to glean lessons learned from their counterterrorist operations in urban areas.” In the words of Michael Schwartz, collectively "punish the families and neighbors of guerrillas until they decide to reveal their identity and location." This tactic had been used in the village of Abu Hishma, and was going to be used in Fallujah.
See: Fallujah is Bush's Dujail.
A specific example of this appears in a New York Times Magazine article on death squads by Peter Maass, May 1, 2005. See the section entitled Threatening to Kill a Suspect's Son. Here's a brief excerpt witnessed by Maass:
Note how Maass speaks of this as if it is routine. Maass had gone on other raids. He highlighted this example, because it illustrated the use of threatened execution, not the aside about "bargaining chips."
Another source on the use of threats against family members is Dahr Jamail. In a January 2007 audio interview with Flashpoints Radio that I transcribed, Jamail described torture continuing at US detention centers. Then he continued:
We need to reframe the issue. George Lakoff has introduced the concept of "framing" issues in the public discourse. The title of this essay is one such attempt. Another example is the phrase "the death tax." Once the mainstream debate on estate taxes is framed as "the death tax," an uphill battle is established. It's hard enough to be in favor of taxes, but being in favor of taxing people upon their death becomes even more implausible. Framing is key.
There can be no such thing as a "war on terrorism." Given ample evidence of domestic spying and police infiltration of organizations, new legal definitions like "enemy combatant" for which Geneva Conventions don't apply, the use of torture and renditions, the use of horrific weapons of war (ala "Shock and Awe"), the unleashing to death squads (ala the Salvador Option), adopting Israeli tactics of punishing the familiy members of insurgents [1], it isn't hyperbole to reframe Bush's war on terrorism to be called "Bush's war of terrorism."
Notes:
[1] One basic principle of urban warfare was described to New York Times reporter Dexter Filkins by a U.S. commander: “the new strategy must punish not only the guerrillas, but also make clear to ordinary Iraqis the cost of not cooperating.” According to Brigadier General Michael A. Vane, “We recently traveled to Israel to glean lessons learned from their counterterrorist operations in urban areas.” In the words of Michael Schwartz, collectively "punish the families and neighbors of guerrillas until they decide to reveal their identity and location." This tactic had been used in the village of Abu Hishma, and was going to be used in Fallujah.
See: Fallujah is Bush's Dujail.
A specific example of this appears in a New York Times Magazine article on death squads by Peter Maass, May 1, 2005. See the section entitled Threatening to Kill a Suspect's Son. Here's a brief excerpt witnessed by Maass:
The [Special Police] commandos reached an isolated farmhouse and detained al-Takhi's son, who looked to be in his early 20's. This was an excellent catch. The son of a suspect usually knows where the suspect is hiding; if not, he can be detained and used as a bargaining chip to persuade the father to surrender.
Note how Maass speaks of this as if it is routine. Maass had gone on other raids. He highlighted this example, because it illustrated the use of threatened execution, not the aside about "bargaining chips."
Another source on the use of threats against family members is Dahr Jamail. In a January 2007 audio interview with Flashpoints Radio that I transcribed, Jamail described torture continuing at US detention centers. Then he continued:
Other things that have become even more rampant, that have been reported on in the past, but are even being more utilized by the US military now are, if there's a particular resistance fighter in a community, they'll figure out sometimes who that is, and they'll go detain his wife and then hold her and say, "If you don't come and turn yourself in we'll begin raping her quite soon and then if you still don't come in, maybe we'll go get your kids too."
So that's basically a standard policy now. I'm getting reports pretty often at this point, and we'll be doing a story on that before too long, so let's be real clear that torture in Iraq is rampant and that's because it is policy.
Labels:
Bush,
collective,
Iraq,
punishment,
tactic,
terrorism,
war
December 30, 2006
The Justice in Executing Saddam Hussein
Saddam Hussein was tried and hanged for his disproportionate actions against the town of Dujail. That alone was the official justification for his execution, without consideration of gassing Kurds, secret police, torture or other acts for which he could have been tried.
It has been argued that Fallujah is Bush's Dujail. But it can also be argued that the accumulated whole of the war crimes in Iraq is Bush's Dujail.
Prime Minister Olmert of Israel has his own Dujail. It's called the disproportionate assault and collective punishment of Lebanon in July 2006.

If Justice is blind and balanced, then we should, someday, witness Bush and Olmert being punished for their Dujails.
It has been argued that Fallujah is Bush's Dujail. But it can also be argued that the accumulated whole of the war crimes in Iraq is Bush's Dujail.
Prime Minister Olmert of Israel has his own Dujail. It's called the disproportionate assault and collective punishment of Lebanon in July 2006.

If Justice is blind and balanced, then we should, someday, witness Bush and Olmert being punished for their Dujails.
Labels:
Bush,
Dujail,
Ehud Olmert,
execution,
Justice,
punishment,
Saddam Hussein
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)