Showing posts with label illegal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label illegal. Show all posts

September 17, 2007

Privatized War is a Black(water) Box

Guest Writer L. Vincent Sebastian

The expansion of Blackwater USA to new locations in Illinois and California is a grave indicator that America is moving in the wrong direction with respect to private military and security contractors (See ~ Blackwater Grows as Support For Iraq Shrinks). The role of these contractors should shrink, not grow, due to a number of legal and moral problems.

Some of the controversies surrounding Blackwater and other private contractors have been covered here previously this year (see - June 26; March 11 (3-Part Series); and February 9). And today, controversy erupted anew when the Iraqi government ordered Blackwater to leave the country after the fatal shooting of eight Iraqi civilians following a car bomb attack against a State Department convoy (see "Iraq expels American security firm" by Robert H. Reid, Associated Press, September 17, 2007).

Questioned in response to this incident, American officials refused to explain the legal authority under which Blackwater operates in Iraq or say whether the company was complying with an order. The real problem here is one of accountability: Private security contractors operating on foreign soil are not really accountable to anyone. By and large, they operate beyond the control of U.S. military and are not subject to military law. At the same time, they have immunity from Iraqi law (akin to diplomatic immunity). Apparently, the only thing holding a contractor in check is the prospect that its client (the State Department in this case) will be dissatisfied and not renew its contract. But in the insider game of no-bid government contracts, how likely is this for the politically connected Blackwater?

Ultimately, the biggest problem with private contractors is a moral one that affects us all. As war becomes increasingly privatized (about 129,000 contractors are currently operating in Iraq), it becomes further removed and concealed from the attention of the American people. The historic role of our government as the legitimate perpetrator of a war shifts to one of manager-at-arms-length of a war carried out by third parties, the contractors. This further distances us, the public, from the war and its consequences, and separates us from the sense of buy-in, participation, oversight, and responsibility we all must have if war is to be waged.

June 9, 2007

Lou Dobbs: White Supremacist Links

Perhaps Lou Dobbs is a dupe, or just sloppy, but his drum beat against undocumented workers exposes a number of white supremacist links.

Madeleine Cosman, Darling of White Nationalist Anti-immigrant Leaders

One of Lou Dobbs' correspondents reported that there had been about 900 case of leprosy for 40 years, but 7,000 cases of leprosy in the US over the previous three years. The story implied that the increase in this disease was caused by undocumented immigrants. Eventually, Lou Dobbs was confronted by Lesley Stahl of 60-Minutes. His response to Stahl was, "If we reported it, it's true."

Eventually, Dobbs had to issue a correction. Lou Dobbs' producer, Christine Romans, eventually said the Lou Dobbs Tonight program got the figures from Madeleine Cosman, published in The Journal of American Physicians and Surgeons, a discredited radical right-wing pseudo journal that includes things like friendly book reviews of How To Talk To A Liberal (If You Must) by Ann Coulter, and Minutemen – The Battle To Secure America’s Border by Jim Gilchrist and Jerome Corsi.

Madeleline Cosman appears to have been a darling of white supremacists opposed to immigration. The following two clips give an idea of the source used by Lou Dobbs:


Madeline Cosman: Lou Dobbs' Unreliable Source on Leprosy Statistics


Madeline Cosman: Lou Dobbs' Source Unreliable Source on Leprosy Statistics

Mexican Plans to Recapture the Southwest

When Lou Dobbs reported that the Mexicans had a plan to recapture the Southwest, he used a graphic from the web site of the Council of Conservative Citizens (CCC), the largest white supremacist group in the US (The CCC is considered the successor of the White Citizens Councils, both headed by St. Louis-based Gordon Lee Baum. Basically, Dobbs served as a mouth piece for the CCC in telling this nutty story. Just another "regrettable" mistake or a patter?

Lou Dobbs Tonight: Platform for Joe McCutchen

Joe McCutchen is a member of the CCC and headlined their meeting in 2006. McCutchen, head of Protect Arkansas Now, appeals to skin heads and neo-nazis, as well as the hardcore, boarder patrol anti-immigrant movement. Just Google the guy, and you'll find gems like this (search for McCutchin) and you'll have to wonder why Dobbs would give him a platform.

There are More

I could go on, but the work has already been done for my by the Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC, 2005). SPLC tracks hate-groups among other things.

Wanna Take Action?

Contact CNN
and provide feedback on the Lou Dobbs Tonight show.