Showing posts with label free market. Show all posts
Showing posts with label free market. Show all posts

February 28, 2010

Left Vs Right

Vocal Tea Party members often turn to historical references to justify their views. Yet, they also seem to have right wing views in support of the "free market" and constitutional rights of corporations. So, my question is, "are Tea Party members for the people or are they for the corporations?" Maybe they actually believe that corporations have the people's best interests at heart? ... as if corporations have hearts.

Left = government of the people, by the people, for the people

Right = government of the corporations, by the corporations, for the corporations.

Adherents to the right wing reasoning seem to believe that the invisible hand of the free market will make all things good. Under this reasoning, it's in the people's best interest that the Wall Street insiders got phat-rich over the last decade AND got bailed out by the tax payers when their system collapsed. Of course, they argue that the collapse was all Clinton's fault, because he forced mortgage companies to sell houses to the poor.

Corporations are also "people" according to America's current laws, or at least according to activist judges making America's laws.

But fear not, slavery was once America's law of the land, and the Supreme Court upheld that law in . Not to be too cynical, history shows we can change the laws of the land. Yes, if we take the multi-generational view of our social struggle, we can envision hope.

BTW: Hit the "Follow" button to the right :-D

gdaeman_scroll_small

September 14, 2008

Suddenly Regulators are the Good Guys

I recently wrote about the Death of the Free Market, by which I meant the free market fundamentalism in which regulation was bad. Watch how quickly the free market touts run from that unquestioned economic principle, which has dominated for the past three decades. You'll hear revisionist statements from both Democrats and Republicans, "We never really meant "free" markets. We've always recognized the necessary role of regulation."

Sorry. Too late. The damage has been done. Now the regulators are attempting to ride to the rescue. Unfortunately, after years of being the bad guys, having budgets and staff cut, the regulators probably don't have the tools and experience needed to do the job.

In response to news about the negotiations to control the collateral damage from the Lehman Brothers' implosion, J.P. Morgan economist Jim Glassman said,
For us to know there's a comprehensive approach going on, that's a constructive theme for the markets.... It's in everyone's interest to take a stab at this and be good public citizens because if this problem keeps spreading, eventually it's going to engulf everybody.

In other words, "The invisible fist of the market is about to pummel us, so we better forget about free market competition and work collectively, outside of the economic paradigm, to resolve this social crisis." Milton Friedman's free market fundamentalism is dead.

Sources:

Washington Post, Major Financial Players Map Out Lehman Options, September 14, 2008.

gdaeman_scroll_small

September 13, 2008

Who Constitutes the US "Financial Oligopoly"?

Here's a clue to the answer:

Participants in Saturday's discussions about the failing Lehman Brothers included executives from Goldman Sachs, JPMorgan Chase, Morgan Stanley, Citigroup and Merrill Lynch.

So much for fairy tales about the so-called "free market." Ah. But don't worry. It's all for our own good. Ever feel like saying "baaaaa"?

I like this one:
Global fears intensified Saturday that the collapse of the country's fourth-largest investment bank would stagger markets and undercut confidence in the U.S. financial system.

As if it hasn't already effectively collapsed. That's today's defininition of a "Free Market;" it's free fall for people with a health-care crisis who are subjected to Senator Biden's Bankruptcy "reform" law, but not for the upper crust free marketeers. OOOoooo "Change is coming." Of course, McCain/Palin are worse.

At least the following statement regarding "bad bets" is half-honest:

Bad bets on real-estate holdings — which have factored into bank failures and taken out other financial companies — have thrust the 158-year-old firm in peril.

True, the decisions were "bets" as are made in gambling halls, now called "trading floors". But they were not "bad" they were "stupid."

Sources:

Emergency meeting on Lehman rescue resumes

gdaeman_scroll_small

September 10, 2008

The Unregulated "Free Market" is Dead

It is now officially acceptable to laugh at anyone who promotes unregulated "free markets." Free markets are promoted by three groups of people: Criminals who are willing to use exploitation to amass wealth, ideologues who operate on deeply held belief systems and are thus blind, or those who lack enough knowledge to understand how the world works.

Unregulated markets allow people to do anything to make money, including changing laws to legalize criminality. Consider the current example of the mortgage brokers who made home sales over the past decade without checking credit. With each house they sold they got fees and had no risk if the mortgages they sold failed. The higher the house price, the bigger the fee. Not all mortgage brokers were exploitative, but the system in which they worked became increasingly corrupt. First line "banks" that underwrite the mortgages were quick to unload the mortgages to avoid risk.

Secondary "financial institutions" that amass mortgages and either sell them in bulk or turn them into bonds to be sold passed on the risk and took their huge profits.

Brokerages that buy and sell such bonds made money on every transaction, never holding any risky mortgages. All the while they told investors the bonds were secure, because the "the real estate is collateral" and the bond rating companies say they're good. Never mind the obvious fact that the real estate was way over valued. This is not a debatable point; not a quibbling point. Few people on earth have not heard, or said themselves that, "If I had to buy my house today, I couldn't afford it"? That's the main street definition of over-valued real estate.

As noted, the bond rating companies are paid handsomely to say the bonds are high grade. Their employees are part of the Wall Street class; gotta be paid a lot to live in Manhattan.

The law firms and lobbyists make sure it is all technically legal by getting corrupt or ideological or stupid elected officials to make it so. Lobbyists got very wealthy carrying the messages between Wall Street and Washington (another no-risk middleman benefiting from the "free market"). Ain't the unregulated free market great for these folks? They've got to love it.

Communications firms, like the ones who produce magazines that touted Enron in the early 1990s, write glitzy stories about maverick businessmen who created "innovative risk diversification systems." These "innovative risk diversification systems" were just fancy ways to "pass the buck" on to pension funds and other investors. The unregulated "free market" seemed so legitimate despite some of us knowing it was a huge scam.

A similar analysis of other industries reveals the same pattern of corruption through all sub-sectors as described above; they all have their lawyers, their accountants, their marketing arms; we saw it in the energy "market" with Enron. That market, by the way, is still totally corrupt. The financial industry, with unregulated hedge funds, is the same. Energy, Real estate, financial, all central to what we call our "economy" and all totally corrupt.

We are now all collective deers staring into the headlights of reality. Obama and McCain will both try to paper over this fundamental failure of "the system". They will do this by bailing out the "free market" and passing the cost to future generations of tax payers; the crisis will magically end, a huge debt will be passed on to future generations, and the corrupt system will continue.

It's an old story, seen as recently as the 1980s Savings and Loan Scandal, even more recently if you count Enron (cost California energy rate payers alone at least $10 Billion). It will change when Americans get very angry with the realization that a small number of people get really really rich off of these "free market" scams. Then, perhaps with very little control, these angry people will do what ever is necessary, using any means available, to put a stop to the corrupt unregulated "free market".

The alternative would be to make real change, far beyond what either major political party is contemplating. That's unlikely because the system is so deeply corrupt it has become a danger to itself and those very few people who benefit from it.

An unregulated "free market" is corrupt by definition, because if there are no rule (regulations) the law of the jungle prevails. Unregulated commerce will inevitably pass debt onto future generations. This is a massive form of exploitation by a minority of the commerce class. Is the majority of our civilization really so easily duped?

gdaeman_scroll_small

September 4, 2008

Economy: A Mess


Stocks plummet after retail, unemployment data

3% drop is big. Watch it swing right back up. Such swings have typically preceded past major economic crashes.... kinda like the nasty wobble before wipe-out, the bright light bulb before burn out, and the wild energy of a fly before death.

Jobless claims jump is bad omen for economy.

"Omen"? It's been a year since the big mortgage melt-dwon, and their still talking about omens for the future?

U.S. House Price Decline Could Be Worse Than Great Depression.

The higher the price, the further it has to fall. Raise your hand if you've heard a friend say, "If I had to buy my house now, I couldn't afford it." A modest house and a solid middle-class income... some speculators got rich and we're paying for it. But don't worry, the free market always corrects itself.

I was a little surprised by the date of a past article of mine. Remember the August 2007 real estate melt-down? Here's what I wrote in May 28, 2007:

Watch the real estate situation unravel this summer. Congress will try to save it, placing the burden on future tax-payers (so much for a "free" market in which bad business decisions are allowed to play out). We've seen it before in the same way the S&L double-scandal was swept under the rug. The twin debts will grow. Eventually, foreigners will diversify out of dollars, more so than they are already, and the US will decline like Spain and Britain did. The "hope" is that the US will do so with grace rather than a holocaust.


Photo Credit: "mess" by skepticillusion.

July 30, 2008

Swinging Wildly

Has anyone noticed that the stock market is swinging wildly? Has anyone ever noticed that, when something is out of control it swings wildly... then, often times, crashes horribly.

Welcome to the self-correcting free market. Fasten your seat belts.

gdaeman_scroll_small

August 25, 2007

Fed Bends Rules for Monopolistic Insiders

The bigger they are, the more monopolistic they are, and the more protection they get from the Federal Reserve. What's wrong with this picture in a competitive "free market" economy?

An August 24 CNNMoney.com article, "Fed bends rules to help two big banks" reports:
August 20 letters from the Fed to Citigroup and Bank of America state that the Fed... has agreed to exempt both banks from rules that effectively limit the amount of lending that their federally-insured banks can do with their brokerage affiliates.

The Glass-Steagall Act, following the 1929 stock market crash, separated investment and commercial banking. It's claimed that Glass-Steagall worked for many years, but then became "anachronistic" as the financial sector modernized. "Commercial banks watched their market share of U.S. financial assets erode from nearly 50% to less than 32%." "Mutual fund assets grew 24% a year while [commercial bank] deposit growth has averaged just 3.4%." These comparisons in a March 1998 article by Nicole Olmstead Coulter are true, but one has to ask if the "modernization" was all healthy in the first place.

Experience suggests that the so-called "modernization" of laws is actually the rigging of arcane rules with the intent of making profits for the sector funding the lobbyists making the "modernization" pitch, and campaign donations, to the US Congress.

Coulter continues, "Through securitization, investment banks have taken away some of banks' traditional markets." "Increasingly, consumers demanded higher yields on their investments." Which could be followed by, "regardless of any underlying fundamentals." Who doesn't want more return? But should we do so if it is predicted to create boom/bust cycles? One can argue that, while in some ways securitization is beneficial, the greed-driven market is designed to drive "securitization" to the brink, as we are now witnessing the effects of runaway morgtage securitization. Cow manure has legitimate value as fertilizer and soil enhancement. Imagine warehouses of bullshit bundled and used as collateral for bonds (it probably exists).

The larger point is, however, that huge commercial banks can become huger if allowed to enter the brokerage business. In 1987, banking laws (Section 20) were changed to allow commercial banks to have subsidiaries that could offer investment services. By 1997, banks had successfully lobbied Congress, and Clinton, to allow banks to underwrite up to 25% of the subsidiaries' revenues. This "essentially wip[ed] out barriers toward bank acquisition of investment banks and securities firms," according to Coulter.

The merger and acquistion flood gates opened. The consolidation reduced diversity in the market place. The big banks accumulated more influence over the market, until ... they began influence the market, and that by text book definition is monopolistic. To help mitigate this, a limit on funding is still supposed to exist between commercial and brokerage operations. But, today's fiscal crisis is so bad, the Fed just bent the rules, proving my point. They can't let the big ones fail, because they too strongly influence the market.

The little ones? Too bad; the market isn't rigged to help the little guys. It isn't really a free market, and we all know it. A growing question is, given that the market is rigged, why don't we rig it to generate broader benefits rather than to enrich a few?

Sources:

CNNMoney.com article, "Fed bends rules to help two big banks", August 24, 2007.

Registered Rep, "Bank/Brokerage Marriages," Nicole Olmstead Coulter, March 1, 1998,